The current unsustainable boom in the Argentine economy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52195/pm.v10i2.197Abstract
Since 2010, Paul Krugman has been suggesting that Greece, Spain, Ireland and other European countries should consider abando-ning the euro and devalue their currencies in order to solve their fiscal difficulties. In January of 2011 Krugman repeated the same prescription, but added that the Argentine default and devalua - tion of 2001-2002 should be taken as an example of what Greece and other European countries in trouble should do to escape the crisis in which they are immersed.
In Krugman’s own words:
Some economists, myself included, look at Europe’s woes and have the feeling that we’ve seen this movie before, a decade ago on another continent - specifically, in Argentina. […] Argentina didn’t simply default on its foreign debt; it also abandoned its link to the dollar, allowing the peso’s value to fall by more than two-thirds. And this devaluation worked: from 2003 onward, Ar-gentina experienced a rapid export-led economic rebound. (Krug-man, 2011a).1
The Argentinian government could not resist the temptation to use the unfortunate words of this Nobel Prize winner to con-gratulate themselves on the success of policies implemented over the last decade.
My objective is to try to clarify what happened in Argentina’s recent economic history, in order to shed light on a current and controversial topic in the field of economic policy.
References
BRUNO, E.A. (2006): «The Failure of Debt-Based Development: Lessons from Argentina», Cato Journal, vol. 26, n.º 2, Spring/ Summer.
CACHANOSKY, R. (2005): «Reservas: valor de mercado y contable» [«Reserves: market value and accounting»], La Nación, oc-tober 23.
— (2009a): «Reservas: la contabilidad creativa» [«Reserves: creative accounting»], La Nación, january 4.
— (2009b): «Reservas del Banco Central: no aclaren que os-curecen» [Central Bank Reserves: do not clarify that which they obscure], La Nación, january 16.
CALVO, G.A., IZQUIERDO, A. y TALVI, E. (2003): «Sudden Stops, the Real Exchange Rate, and Fiscal Sustainability: Argentina’s Lessons,» NBER Working Papers 9828, National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc.
GARCÍA HAMILTON, J.I. (2005): «Historical Reflections on the Splen-dor and Decline of Argentina», Cato Journal, vol. 25, n.º 3.
GUIDO, P. y LAZZARI, G. (2003): «Apuntes sobre la caída de la eco-nomía argentina. (Se puede evitar todo, menos las conse-cuencias)», [«Notes on the Crash of the Argentine Economy: Everything may be avoided, except the consequences»] Li-bertas, n.º 38, ESEADE, Buenos Aires, may.
HANKE, S.H. (2002): «Argentina’s Current Political-Economic Cri-sis», Congressional Testimony, march 5.
— (1999): «Dollarization for Argentina», Journal of Applied Cor-porate Finance, Volume 12, Issue 1, pp. 121-126, Spring.
HANKE, S.H. y KRUS, N. (2009): «World Hyperinflations», Cato Wor-king Paper. n.º 8, august 15, 2012. Forthcoming in: Randall Parker and Robert Whaples (eds.) (2013) The Handbook of Major Events in Economic History, London: Routledge Pu-blishing. (expected publication date: Summer 2013).
HANKE, S.H. y SCHULER, K. (2002): «What went wrong in Ar-gentina?», Central Banking Journal, volume XII, number 3, february.
HIDALGO, J.C. (2012): «Krugman’s Love Affair with the Kirchner Model in Argentina», Cato at Liberty, may 7.
KATZ, C. (2005): «The effects of paying off the IMF», National Uni-versity of Buenos Aires, december 20.
KRUGMAN, P. (2012): «Down Argentina Way», The Conscience of a Liberal, may 3.
— (2011a): «Can Europe be Saved?», The New York Times, ja-nuary 21.
— (2011b): «Don’t Cry for Argentina», The Conscience of a Li-beral, june 23.
— (2011c): «Unacceptable Success», The Conscience of a Liberal, october 24.
— (2010): «Default, Devaluation or What?», The Conscience of a Liberal, may 4.
LIZARDO, R. y MOLLICK, A.V. (2009): «Can Latin America Prosper by Reducing the Size of Government?», Cato Journal, vol. 29, nº. 2, Spring/Summer.
LÓPEZ MURPHY, R., ARTANA, D. y NAVAJAS F. (2003): «The Argen-tine Economic Crisis», Cato Journal, vol. 23, n.º 1, Spring/ Summer.
MOFFETT, M. y TURNER, T. (2012): «Argentina to Seize Control of Oil Firm», The Wall Street Journal, april 17.
MORALES SOLÁ, J. (2009): «Bajo el gobierno de gremialistas y pi-queteros» [«Under the government of unionists and pro-testers»], La Nación, november 8.
NIEMIETZ, K. (2009): «The nationalisation of retirement savings accounts in Argentina», Economic Affairs 01/2009; 29(1): 49-53.
O’CONNOR, E.A. y VIGNALE, J. (2011): «Sistema Tributario Argen-tino. Un análisis comparativo de la contribución por sec-tores productivos y de la equidad sectorial» [«The Argenti-ne Tax System. A comparative analysis of the contributions of productive sectors and sectoral equity»], Programa de Análisis de Coyuntura-Escuela de Economía, Facultad de Cien-cias Económicas, UCA, Buenos Aires, (november).
O’GRADY, M.A. (2012): «Kirchner Grabs the Central Bank», The Wall Street Journal, april 1, 2012.
RAVIER, A. y LEWIN, P. (2012): «The Subprime Crisis», The Quaterly Journal of Austrian Economics, vol. 15, n.º 1, Spring, pp. 45-74.
ROMIG, S. (2012): «Argentina Stems Capital Flight in Third Quarter by Blocking Dollar Buying», The Wall Street Journal, no-vember 16.
SCHWEIMLER, D. (2008): «Argentina’s farm row turns to crisis», BBC News, june 18.
STANG, S. (2011): «Se usan sin control fondos de la ANSES» [«Un-controlled use of ANSES funds»], La Nación, Argentina, february 21.
TURNER, T. (2011a): «Argentina Fines More Economists Over In-flation Estimates», The Wall Street Journal, april 12.
— (2011b): «In Argentina, Cloudy Trade Policies Hamstring Importers», The Wall Street Journal, december 19.
VÁSQUEZ, I. (1996): «The Brady Plan and Market-based solutions to debt crises», Cato Journal, vol. 16, n.º 2.
